Ms Paige’s Peanut Butter Cookie Balls

These decadent peanut butter cookie balls are delicious and easy to make on a Tolly of any size!
Ms Paige’s Peanut Butter Cookie Balls – Liz Trythall (MsLyzz)

Category: Cookie, Recipe

Cookies by MsLyzz

*** Boat tested and Tollyclub approved ****

Peanut Butter Cookie Balls


1 Krusteaz butter sugar cookie mix
2 eggs
2 tbsp water
1 jar (24 oz) Skippy Extra Chunky Peanut Butter (Costco size 😊 I use the whole jar)
1 bag Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups (miniatures for bite size cookies or regular for larger cookies )


Mix cookie mix, eggs and peanut butter.
Spoon into round balls
Place Reese’s in center covering Reese’s and roll into a ball
Place on cookie sheet
Bake at 325 convection oven (14 minutes ) OR 350 regular oven (8-10 minutes )

Yield: 36 small or 18 large

© Liz Trythall (MsLyzz)



See more Tollyclub recipes or send your favourite Tolly recipes to share with other members